Getting a Second Opinion After a Terminal Diagnosis: Why It Matters and How

A serious or terminal diagnosis is one of the most frightening things a person or family can face. In this moment, the instinct to act — to start treatment, to accept the prognosis — is powerful. But taking the time to get a second opinion is one of the most important things you can do. It doesn't delay meaningful care, and it can change everything.

Second Opinions Change Outcomes

Studies consistently find that second opinions for serious diagnoses result in changes to diagnosis, treatment plan, or prognosis in a significant proportion of cases. A 2017 Mayo Clinic study found that 21% of second opinion patients received a completely different diagnosis, and 66% received a refined or changed diagnosis. For cancer specifically, second opinions at major cancer centers frequently reveal additional treatment options, clinical trial eligibility, or different prognoses than the initial assessment.

Where to Seek a Second Opinion

NCI-Designated Cancer Centers — for any cancer diagnosis, the National Cancer Institute's network of comprehensive cancer centers (findable at cancer.gov) represents the highest level of oncology expertise and clinical trial access
Academic medical centers — major university hospitals (Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, Johns Hopkins, UCSF, etc.) have multidisciplinary teams and condition-specific expertise across a wide range of diagnoses
Disease-specific centers of excellence — for rare diseases or specific conditions, the NIH's National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (rarediseases.info.nih.gov) can help identify specialists
Remote/telemedicine second opinions — most major academic centers now offer second opinion consultations that don't require travel; records are reviewed remotely and results communicated by phone or video

What to Bring to a Second Opinion

All imaging (CD of scans, not just reports)
Pathology slides or tissue blocks (request these specifically — very important)
Lab results and bloodwork
Operative or procedure reports
List of current medications
Your specific questions, written down in advance

Insurance Coverage

Most health insurance plans, including Medicare and Medicaid, cover second opinion consultations. Some plans specifically encourage or require second opinions for serious diagnoses. Call member services before scheduling to confirm coverage and any pre-authorization requirements.

Related Guides

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you always get a second opinion after a terminal diagnosis?

Getting a second opinion after a serious or terminal diagnosis is almost always worthwhile, and most experienced oncologists and specialists expect and encourage it. Here's why: (1) Diagnoses can be wrong — pathology, imaging interpretation, and clinical assessment all involve human judgment; misdiagnosis rates in serious illness are higher than most patients (and physicians) expect; a second opinion can catch errors in the original diagnosis; (2) Treatment options differ — different medical centers and physicians may have different expertise, access to clinical trials, or approaches to the same diagnosis; a second opinion from a specialty center (particularly an NCI-designated cancer center, a major academic medical center, or a condition-specific specialist) may reveal options that were not presented initially; (3) Prognosis estimates vary — survival estimates and prognostic framing differ among physicians; a "you have 6 months" statement from one physician may not be what a second physician would say; (4) Clinical trials — a specialty center with relevant clinical trials may have options not available through a community oncologist. Getting a second opinion does NOT mean you distrust your doctor. Most physicians actively support second opinions, recognizing that they improve care and that physicians themselves seek second opinions when they or their family members are seriously ill. If your physician discourages you from seeking a second opinion, that itself is important information.

How do you get a second opinion without offending your doctor?

Most physicians expect and respect patients seeking second opinions, particularly for serious diagnoses. You don't need permission from your doctor to seek a second opinion, and in most cases you don't need to apologize for it. Practical approach: (1) You can simply say: "I'd like to get a second opinion at [institution]. Can you help me get my records sent over?" Most physicians will facilitate this without objection; (2) If you're not ready to have the direct conversation, you can contact the second opinion center directly — they can often tell you what records they need and help you request them from the first physician's office; (3) You can frame it positively: "I want to make sure I understand all my options, and I think getting a second opinion will help me feel confident about the path forward." This is true and is hard to object to; (4) Some patients worry about damaging the relationship with their primary physician. In reality, a physician who is offended by a patient seeking a second opinion is a physician worth reconsidering — seeking information about your own serious illness is your right as a patient. If the relationship with the first physician is ongoing, most patients find that a second opinion, even one that confirms the first physician's assessment, strengthens rather than damages the relationship by building the patient's confidence.

What should you look for in a second opinion for a terminal diagnosis?

Key considerations when seeking a second opinion for a serious illness: (1) Specialty expertise — for most serious diagnoses, the second opinion is most valuable at an institution with specific expertise in your condition; for cancer, this means an NCI-designated comprehensive cancer center (cancer.gov has a directory); for rare diseases, condition-specific centers of excellence or major academic medical centers; (2) Pathology review — one of the most important and overlooked elements of a second opinion is having the pathology (biopsy slides or tissue blocks) reviewed by the pathologists at the second opinion center, not just the clinical assessment; pathology interpretation errors are not uncommon and are one of the most common sources of diagnostic revision at second opinion; (3) Tumor board presentation — at major cancer centers, a second opinion may involve presentation of your case to a multidisciplinary tumor board (oncology, surgery, radiation, pathology, radiology) rather than a single physician review; (4) Clinical trial eligibility — ask specifically whether you might be eligible for any clinical trials; academic centers and specialty centers are more likely to have relevant trials; (5) Clarity about what you want to know — going into a second opinion, decide what your key questions are: Is the diagnosis correct? Are there treatment options I haven't been told about? Am I eligible for clinical trials? What is the prognosis with different treatment approaches? Having clear questions leads to a more useful consultation.